The Deductive Problem of Evil Essays

The Deductive Problem of Evil Essays

Length: 1523 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Deductive Problem of Evil

 
   One of the major philosophical debates concerning God's existence involves the problem of evil.  The problem has two basic formulations, one is deductive, the other inductive.  The deductive form of the problem asks the following:  Is the existence of evil logically compatible with a necessarily benevolent and necessarily omnipotent being?  One of the philosophers who discusses the problem is Richard Gale.  I will begin this essay by outlining the deductive problem of evil according to Gale.  I will then try to refute the deductive argument and prove that the existence of evil is indeed logically compatible with a benevolent and omnipotent being.  A conclusion will then follow.

The deductive argument has been around since the time of Epicurus.1   In its simplest form, the problem is stated as follows:

1. God is omnipotent

2. God is wholly good

3. Evil exists

Proponents of the argument believe the set of propositions is logically inconsistent, i.e. that at least one proposition must be false.  This basic formulation is problematic.  It presupposes two important things:  First, that God and evil are logically incompatible; and second, that God's omnipotence is unlimited.  It is obvious, then, that some additional premises are needed if the argument is to succeed.  W.L. Mackie was one of the first philosophers to provide these additional premises.2  He adds the following premises to the set:

4. A wholly good (omni-benevolent) being eliminates and prevents every evil he can.3

5. There are no limits to what an omnipotent being can do.

With the insertion of these revised principles, Mackie hopes to deduce a contradiction, namely that evil does not exist (from 1,...


... middle of paper ...


...Ibid.  P. 103

8 Some philosophers have referred to this idea as the Condition of Reasonable Epistemic Access (COREA)


Works Consulted:

Christlieb, Terry. "Which Theisms Face an Evidential Problem of Evil?" Faith and Philosophy 9 (January 1992): 45-64.

Griffin, David. Evil Revisited: Responses and Reconsiderations. Albany: SUNY Press, 1991.

-         - -. God, Power and Evil: A Process Theodicy. Philadelphia: Westminster Press, 1976.

Plantinga, Alvin. "Epistemic Probability and Evil." Archivio di Filosophia 56 (1988).

- - -. "The Probabilistic Argument from Evil." Philosophical Studies 35 (January 1979): 1-53.

Reichenbach, Bruce. "Natural Evils and Natural Laws: A Theodicy for Natural Evils." International Philosophical Quarterly 16 (June, 1976): 179-88.

Rowe, William L. "Ruminations About Evil," Philosophical Perspectives 5 (1991).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

J.L. Mackie's Evil and Omnipotence Essay

- J.L. Mackie's "Evil and Omnipotence" The philosopher J.L. Mackie wrote a very convincing piece on the problem of evil called “Evil and Omnipotence,” in which he attempts to show that one of the following premises must be false in order for them to be consistent with each other. #1. God is omnipotent. #2. God is morally perfect. #3. Evil exists. The problem of evil is a deductive a priori argument who’s goal is to prove the non-existence of God. In addition to Mackie’s three main premises he also introduces some “quasi-logical” rules that give further evidence to his argument....   [tags: Philosophy Philosophical Evil Mackie Essays]

Powerful Essays
1664 words (4.8 pages)

An Internal Conflict With The Problem Of Evil Essay

- 1.) Describe the extent to which- if any- you personally have been troubled by the problem of evil. According to Vardy and Arliss (2003) “Evil is one of the deepest and most central problems of human existence—a problem that every individual and every age must face for itself” (p.6). Life consists of successes and hardships. At a young age, my mother always told me that obtaining an education is the key to a successful and bright future. Today, I am attending Felician University, and I am half way through my long and stressful undergraduate career....   [tags: Meaning of life, Human, Problem of evil, Life]

Powerful Essays
789 words (2.3 pages)

The Problem of Evil Essay

- Introduction One of the oldest dilemmas in philosophy is also one of the greatest threats to Christian theology. The problem of evil simultaneously perplexes the world’s greatest minds and yet remains palpably close to the hearts of the most common people. If God is good, then why is there evil. The following essay describes the problem of evil in relation to God, examines Christian responses to the problem, and concludes the existence of God and the existence of evil are fully compatible. Body “The problem of evil is often divided between the logical and evidential problems.” At the heart of each problem is the belief that the existence of God and the existence evil are incompatible....   [tags: God and Evil are Compatible]

Powerful Essays
2238 words (6.4 pages)

Essay on The Problem of Evil

- The problem of evil is the notion that, how can an all-good, all-powerful, all-loving God exists when evil seems to exist also. The problem of evil also gives way to the notion that if hell exists then God must be evil for sending anyone there. I believe both of these ideas that God can exist while there is evil and God is not evil for sending anyone to hell. I believe hell exists in light of the idea that God is holy and just. The larger is how anyone can go to heaven. I will try to answer the problem of evil with regards to the problem of heaven and hell....   [tags: God, Evil, Hell, Heaven, Existance, Good]

Powerful Essays
1660 words (4.7 pages)

Essay on The Problem of Evil

- My claim that we have evil in this world because of our libertarian freedom does not fully answer the notion of “the problem of evil”. Saying we have evil in this world is just like saying we have bad decisions in this world. Bad decisions just like evil do not have a form. Every decision that God makes is a good decision therefore God cannot do evil. Human beings initiated evil. In fact, the first human beings (Adam and Eve) gave ongoing birth to evil because everyone ultimately came from them....   [tags: God, Evil, Hell, Heaven, Existance, Good]

Powerful Essays
1123 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on The Problem with Evil in Religion

- The problem of evil is widely considered as the most detrimental problem to the monotheist. It is also the primary objection to the overall existence of God. The problem is very easy to comprehend: If God is an all-perfect, all-knowing, all-powerful deity then why do we live in a world with any imperfection or negativity at all. Why do bad things happen at all. Especially to the good people in the world and the millions of innocent people who suffer on a daily basis. Gottfreid Leibniz was a philosopher, who took aim at the problem and wished to point out that the existence of evil and God are compatible of evil and and the typical logic is: (1) if God was an all-powerful, all-knowing and all...   [tags: Evil and God]

Powerful Essays
1266 words (3.6 pages)

Essay about God And The Problem With Sin And Evil

- God and the Problem with Sin and Evil Before one understands why there is evil in the world one must ask two important questions. First, who is God and what is His personality/characteristics, and second, what is sin and how does it affect humans and their relationship with God. By understanding these two different types of questions, one will understand the implications of evil and therefore be able to establish if God truly is evil or if sin truly is the root of all the evil in the world. Sin is defined by Erickson when he refers to the work of Satan, saying, “In their case the god of this world has blinded the minds of unbelievers, to keep them from seeing the light of the gospel of the...   [tags: Good and evil, God, Omnipotence]

Powerful Essays
1674 words (4.8 pages)

The Problem of Evil in Our World Essay

- During World War II about 65 million people died, during the famines in British India about 27 million people died, during the fall of the Ming Dynasty about 25 million people died, during the Stalin Dictatorship about 20 million people died (White), during the Boston Marathon Bombing three people died (“Boston Marathon Terror Attack Fast Facts”), and according to the Central Intelligence Agency out of 100,000 people, 839 die per year (“The World Factbook”). Have you ever wondered how many of those 829 people are actually murdered, stripped out of their lives....   [tags: Good vs Evil]

Powerful Essays
1313 words (3.8 pages)

Augustine and The Problem of Evil Essay

- In the beginning, God created the world. He created the earth, air, stars, trees and mortal animals, heaven above, the angels, every spiritual being. God looked at these things and said that they were good. However, if all that God created was good, from where does un-good come. How did evil creep into the universal picture. In Book VII of his Confessions, St. Augustine reflects on the existence of evil and the theological problem it poses. For evil to exist, the Creator God must have granted it existence....   [tags: God, Creation, Evil]

Powerful Essays
899 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on The Problem of Evil

- The Problem of Evil The Judaeo/Christian tradition is founded upon the belief that there exists a supernatural personal being who is the ultimate creator and to which all other beings owe their existence. Three major characteristics are ascribed to this being (God?), that of being wholly good (omnibenevolent), wholly powerful (omnipotent) and all knowing (omniscient). This is the foundation of western religious thought and it is these characteristics and their relationship with evil which comprise the theme of this essay....   [tags: Christianity Religion Religious Biblical Evil Ess]

Powerful Essays
2443 words (7 pages)