Differences Between Science And Pseudo Science Essay

Differences Between Science And Pseudo Science Essay

Length: 1094 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

It is important to distinguish forms of reasoning in science in order to distinguish between science and pseudo-science. This essay will explore the concept of the scientific method and how it utilises inductive reasoning, followed by an exploration of Karl Popper’s argument that when scientists explore their ideas through inductive reasoning, they make it impossible for science to hold any more credibility than pseudo-science. This will then be followed a dismantling of Popper’s argument and deductive reasoning proposal on the basis that inductive reasoning is justified, falsifiable, and allows for scientific progress.
First, before exploring the possible reasons to dismiss inductive reasoning, it is worth understanding completely how it is applied and justified for application. A helpful argument in understanding induction itself is Russell’s, in which he gives the example that if we hear thunder, it is reasonable to conclude that preceding that thunder came lightning based on our experiences of these occurrences in nature. This idea of past experience is then used to justify the theory of induction, assuming that if we observe that A often happens in relation to B, then we can reasonably conclude that A and B are somehow connected. This also is how the scientific method essentially works. A theory is proposed, followed by an experiment to test said theory, and once the experiment has been repeated to ensure that we have reason enough to believe that A and B cause C, it is accepted as the truth. Thus, the scientific method is the application of induction into practice.
In Karl Popper’s paper The Problem of Induction, however, Popper argues that induction is not adequate justification to warrant a reasonable conclusion. In fact...


... middle of paper ...


...g on the fact that we can breach these inevitable gaps of knowledge and still find a conclusion. As Kuhn comments, science requires a definitive paradigm in which we can commit to, because without it, there would be no scientific advancement. In this sense, the inductive reasoning used in the scientific method is justified, as our understanding of scientific truths and all scientific advancement relies on its existence.
While Popper’s qualms about inductive reasoning appear to be justified, it nonetheless proves itself to be the less-problematic approach to scientific learning. This approach need not be flawless for it to be functional in its practical application in the world, and for us to justify its continued use. It simply needs to allow progress, which Popper’s overly-cautious deductive approach evidentially does not allow, at least not on a comparable scale.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Science, Non Science And Pseudo Science

- When it comes to the word ‘science’ most of the people have some kind of knowledge about science or when they think of it there is some kind of image related to science, a theory, scientific words or scientific research, many different sorts of ideas float into an individual’s mind. Every individual has a different perception about science and how he/she perceives it. This illustrates that each individual can identify science in some sort of form. This indicates that science plays a vital role in our everyday lives (Lederman & Tobin, 2002)....   [tags: Scientific method, Theory, Science, Pseudoscience]

Strong Essays
1482 words (4.2 pages)

The Development of the Science of ‘Race’ Essay

- ... It is clear to see from the interviews that this notion of ‘black superiority’ when it comes to sport, is engrained into society, an example of this comes from P6 when asked ‘what is the dominant race within your sport?’ replied ‘every sport is dominated by black people’. Many of the interviewees from both sports state, that when you are younger you do not notice the colour of peoples skin. From this it can be said as you mature through society it is then that racial stereotyping is more apparent, hence racial stereotyping is a social construct (Gouldburg, 1990)....   [tags: hereditary and racial traits]

Strong Essays
1070 words (3.1 pages)

Differences and Similarities Between Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro and The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood

- The purpose of this essay is to analyse and compare the narrative situations proposed by Franz Stanzel in the dystopian novels Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro and The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood. For this aim, I am going to focus on the aspects focalization (reflection), relationship reader-narrator, narrative distance, knowledge, and reliability and demonstrate that they affect the interpretation of the novel by readers in a significant way. In the end, I will draw conclusions on how these techniques serve to alienate the narratives from their science fiction setting to set even more disconcerting issues about human’s existence....   [tags: narrative situations, science-fiction, characters]

Strong Essays
1820 words (5.2 pages)

SIGMA: Pseudo Random Number Generator Essay

- Abstarct— The field of pseudo random number generation is important as well as not much explored. In present manuscript, we explores the possibility of a new Pseudorandom Random Number Generator and gives its testing results on NIST test battery. Keyword— Random Number Generator, NIST statistical test suite, SIGMA I. INTRODUCTION A pseudo-random bit sequence is an output of any deterministic algorithm, which generates a wide number of pseudo-random bits that every set of bits has an equal chance of being chosen from the universe of numbers [1]....   [tags: algorithm, pseudo-random bit sequence, NIST]

Strong Essays
1640 words (4.7 pages)

The Differences Between Popular Science Disciplines Essay

- Positivism was the ideology that initially underpinned all disciplines of early sciences and describes a belief that the complete objective truth can be reached. Natural scientists today hold the universal belief that a truth can repeatedly be exampled until it is falsified by way of methodical research, indicating a positivist approach which incorporates an objective reality. However as time and advancements has progressed, social scientists have embraced the ideology of probabilism. This is the notion that where the subject matter incorporates numerous anomalies and contingencies, the appropriate action is to downsize the explanations to accurately fit the probabilities of the work (Duus-O...   [tags: Natural Sciences, Social Sciences]

Strong Essays
1289 words (3.7 pages)

Science Fiction Differences Between Britain and America Essay

- “Live long and prosper” may be the words which bring back good memories for the average geek in America but this may not be the case for a typical British geek. This is despite the fact that science fiction series in television have been hugely popular in both the U.S. and the U.K. all throughout history. After the 1960s, ‘New Wave’ science fiction began to take over television screens. ‘New Wave’ refers to science fiction which was characterized by a high degree of experimentation (Wolfe). It was during this time when the U.S and the U.K started to telecast science fiction series which had a huge impact on society....   [tags: Science Fiction]

Strong Essays
1429 words (4.1 pages)

Differing Definitions of Politics Essay

- In the article “Politics and Pseudo-Politics: A Critical Evaluation of Some Behavioural Literature” published in The American Political Science Review author Christian Bay creates an interesting and divisive definition of the word politics in response to his frustration with the ambiguous behavioural research and literature taking place in “the discipline that bravely calls itself Political Science.” Although Bay’s definition for politics assists in “guiding and interpreting (Political Scientist’s) empirical work” it is too specific to be used as a definition that encompasses the larger meaning of the word....   [tags: political science, Christian Bay, pseudopolitics]

Strong Essays
1452 words (4.1 pages)

Essay about The Differences Between Science And Pseudoscience

- Karl Popper was a 20th century Austrian-British Philosopher who authored the paper Conjectures and Refutations, The Growth of Scientific Knowledge. In this paper, Popper discussed several questions and issues that he had with the philosophy of science. He first discussed the difference between science and pseudoscience. He defined science as using an empirical method (induction) that follows observations or experiments. Pseudoscience (metaphysics) also relies on observational methods, but does not meet scientific standards....   [tags: Scientific method, Falsifiability, Theory]

Strong Essays
1028 words (2.9 pages)

Gender Differences in Mathematics and Science Learning Essay

- Gender problems adjoining mathematics and science learning have been investigated for decades. Nevertheless, the current climate calls for even more research endeavors to contest statements and beliefs that “innate differences between men and women might be one reason fewer women succeed in science and math careers”. This particular belief may be challenged from the success of all-girl private school environments where 90% of the student population take two full years of science and “go on to major in sciences at Stanford, UCLA, Yale, Princeton, Johns Hopkins, and, yes, Harvard”....   [tags: classes, environment, research]

Strong Essays
595 words (1.7 pages)

"Cargo Cult" Science Essay

- Cargo cult science is an expression used to designate what is also known as pseudo-science. The physicist, Richard Feynman first used this term during his famous speech at the California Institute of Technology in 1974. He used this term when making an analogy to the cult of cargo planes in the South Seas. During the war, Islanders saw airplanes land bringing numerous useful goods; they desired to see the planes landing again. They decided to built airstrips, placed fires along the trails, built a wooden hut where a man sits with two pieces of wood on his head mimicking a helmet and bamboo sticks as antennas - it's the air traffic controller - and they are waiting for the planes land....   [tags: Science]

Strong Essays
934 words (2.7 pages)